zP 7R`N ƍ)RFO' J77qH)sq@4s3G9QRdѓ@
C>jOPG9E4 {f h(fhq֎b PE/j
J1@jQRQHb H:Դ Ըj1F
J)v1Hb
R&)sKA ( ))q(ǥKQ@%- ⒌PF;)h ǵ&h('ڀ
(>{QLBuH~( 4F-C0=( zSIaa G? ( J1RPE&HEhXҐT&x=1ғ1AIv)6hFE;{ѴԻiq@X:уTsғ "}8iq\)gzbhAQMFy)F3M4fGOZnhqK '4v FM(>f(~4:}ޓސ
1I ўTbYcR*q'Z S"r˒M?6KLRNx@bF3@ ۃ^RxhN=)qJTS9cRK\Pq zS{у~4 (?Jp␎hg4 &1֍h< Z Kъ`AN F0hNh @Ru-cҔu :PJ3KΌPE(zE )v1>EڌӨ m/Kޗ@7/QK^zQ{Қ;\ўzR ;QG^; sEZIKG(ǵ~ 1F=:R@. Q@(ҟc@Qڏz@-((
Z _֓):Pϥ qJsi=sHa҂xh <4w#Ҁ
?Z 4LPIޗ9J`? sҒ
)3G|fQLяʎ(f)撀1GcC@ ( \ZL{P);ъ7Rb
qϽZN:P 4n8 .i3FE!!rqIZCN8@ 3Iv'ӭ1SI@qHz!Ɛғ>: Ri2i9ϵ/z BNi{Rp MzL%i HH&hM4sLBIZ3ހJ(M! PsE j)1ȥ< CӞ{w=> g3A'h == h'^`b
ݩ
) `v ֒ zE/z o("qF &ss(h
q)(:})I Bh9u'
惜S2z fyG4zӱJ hI;U+4cW<&6v; >)J9l
Sp}v
g *Bf6 #N̓ir)8)0G4O&G BRAȧQY8S Lb`2N5;K}xm%cSH /si#Ո9H22=#$7heϲh qnV>F0 U{FF*ۉ9,F t LsJ i4c R uIKz :P(րZ: j@p1ҀԹ RځKIʎ vh=iZ;A<ϭ.iZP
`/4g4 J
'zw4>P:wajNqߊ=)E %/9SA PQ(( 4 :bN:'Nv@= (>dw@iOJ^h P:(Fh=8 {
9H4% ɠ
) 1A:}h( sJQ _ZL юԴ PF(iG\P
9u4P(>ԀJ: @ҀϽ֎Ԙ=sHOKh 9 i1Ab84Q:QF)B(y4=i;u@ʌRtLR( ~4 1F}'h
!3(0)p3HO f R( SG9ϨygLF}i BE.qM RT њNԙ(iqoK@=i@ uH@i
=h,( ǽ-I1iInMbjn:\ƀcH궥z_fTJ5(%֘ڂ# DmoYYʟ\@- O I4Ԫgy^- DXh&4̈́lkYDe\bHXf
>b1Uc(;N*qEq:J}KpHZǀɧ\D'!ڶ(`A{#ZTxosTv[gs{z ya#n42Ҷi[=`r3 bD z( ZAҖ-!ڀp3IҌR4d}(4 ^ 14~4 His@(j4 ځFqF{ Rn( =&⁁@> &}/ c bQ zKڀxg'.h@8⎽ c)r)9 11K8L`qKHH
iD %aځfJx zs@FFrGZ0sI 䞤4 LzPEzA`@ zQ_z(4.="zSF)Nh0z9z 1Iߚu&8 /@H)hiLsF=KьwQAh9 Q){R{RE K:`# Ɠ1OIڗ&0=hw 9恋sA4ui w(jCL0 v- h( 0?;P}(;hҌ昀E'S@GgQL P}3Gh;Q`PHi{P!;QE &9dQP њ; G|i ww)QAǡ )2
.:R@<1JqIޓ /=y h`}'GJ` SE Z3BސE &y=i Z`})=)G R Q1KN(Iȥ<( 'Kނy?Z G8? !9?Z2y'C@4ON(cQJIJLҀ(@ P{Rs w֓>g 0sIz3A&HW84 4 Ҝ9LE/=;:P xj!5 !时xϭFh g֓8@s@t@u FF=3@(sI3A> {P*(
+Lg&c/+QI oZ$?99-;ft()]Zr7/MxG 78@YӧhQ%yv"p :(l7d $1;Uk89Ehhd(mahݲ{)A
9Qޛm$.1zQE$ 1t41Gڊ(61Fh KE(( A ^E PQzE "E %( ( QE^b( ( QERh8( uQE (E( QL4QE EPL(@OE &J7zE Qn ѻb g) L( 2h{ќ}(3QLG n /$ J_ FPi@PNG
IHDR n k pHYs ' 'iQ
MiCCPPhotoshop ICC profile xڝSwX>eVBl "#Y a@Ņ
VHUĂ
H(gAZU\8 ܧ}zy&j 9R<: OHɽH g yx~t?o p.$P&W " R .T Sd
ly|B"
I> ة آ (G$@ `UR, @".Y2G vX@` B, 8 C L0ҿ_pH ˕͗K3w!lBa)f "#HL 8?flŢko">! N_puk[ V h]3 Z
zy8@ P<
%b0>3o~@ z q@qanvRB1n#Dž)4\,XP"MyRD!ɕ2 w
ONl~Xv @~- g42y @+ ͗ \L D*A aD@ $<B
AT:18
\p` Aa!:b""aH4 Q"rBj]H#-r9\@ 2G1Qu@ Ơst4]k =Kut }c1fa\E`X&cX5V5c X7va$^lGXLXC%#W 1'"O%zxb:XF&! !%^'_H$ɒN
!%2I IkHH-S>iL&m O:ňL $RJ5e?2BQͩ:ZImvP/S4u%͛Cˤ-Кigih/t ݃ EЗkw
Hb(k{/LӗT02goUX**|:V~TUsU?y TU^V}FUP թ U6RwRPQ__c
FHTc!2eXBrV,kMb[Lvv/{LSCsfffqƱ9ٜJ!
{--?-jf~7zھbrup@,:m:u 6Qu>cy Gm 7046l18c̐ckihhI'&g5x>fo b4ekVyVVI\,mWlPW :˶vm))Sn1
9a%m ;t;|rtuvlp4éĩWggs5KvSmnz˕ҵܭm=}M.]=AXq㝧/^v^Y^ O&0m[{`:>=e>>z"=#~~~;yN`k 5/ >B
Y roc3g,Z0&L ~oL̶Gl i})*2.QStqt,֬Yg;jrvgjlRlc웸xEt$ =sl3Ttcܢ˞w|/%ҟ3 gAMA |Q cHRM z% u0 ` : o_F ;IDATx͋ י{e#xHv r-!F h!:-$lIc,LhgL<62V-? h`A4^htEKjo}S<羷Wo2B( p 7 p 7 p 7 $b! jӓ=;}7Ϯߏozɝb)˹]埍 ԡ! 'q 1n_ rЎu}#J B@ |힎V yzIw6n_{>In )J+
*vc/a[=ۇĥ{G% Ή{x4~<0 <9<]-ae>=`.p Eqon<}6x ~S1}n X>::_^ mc
@A[:m @&: )7kU#g ? 7 `ALI
m;>vuk WC 6?wT>|ꉟ7 `U E 6MpT @8@ЦImy0 n 8h tI{d d-p@oŏ0 C^C/ԁ4~ޕP nОo'h~C|p@B,φR A: Cr"p@ TEQL'7Õpaz+η
-ɆuʉE ЂߔWF a yv~7 4n hPS . y{̏b{<?U 0"I L!>D N\Fj r^ƮWO\qֈ@srۯ[N=.jfsbşrT*=SI ;;KK/pwtA?7}a *Bn+M>ߔ /=7,xWvN;m@NNQ x ܽZr# 6Y|foVU\>6oa[ v~DbSON֧5GoDv&1'"Mă 7 <]}n GzOuApk ^=lo>Z߳rc6*\ 1:_\U7}j~o<ȹF6"z emϹ-nA[a;/ =Ν>z~]} ^yT N iF??t5<8Fݮ ]u;ik=A4C Q껡 ie.zqTĮ O l@9 ?vʻev% Ҏ8E'44Tߟ& T?? ޣtX2Bjjɮ8RuYcx7OgA,YGNa _9kӣ(VFVo?ءg;Qx7[YF$]w绌0h[Smefŏmuxnߣ-\ $hw3ڞ˝}:NC\6=mAbqAg V&CF^mQ_v;xA^}lorx7;auۏ. {/u6`fᶯ0E"CͤWtZn_+0S'u&pGz;=[= "A>L w ܂0
mQE|+?8uHlO[3' NdARgvv0T;.bIAjӑ[̗m
|w'D
"= }ՃHK5`Mb}ƓJm'p;m
:s;69^u%`vlD3:Xr6?8mкwZAb@w6|m*{]ОmQk>W_cM,ʫY | wE2?otQŹ_n v <# <9oBryn 썈O1 /hӧ n'R
,bʞ{殦VEɯI;\C/4=D&lVUF)'TE1hwuÈWo|QEq(_ Pw(SnF_ţɕXgk-l o:ZEiw= ,?||7hmd[SH jܮn@̤w|{j1e[u&TzK4f[do'V?UNr ~.&V
}nv`b@B:VVK ͶYY\O|m| FB spMeZ4c~2:yx
NEf4FBE83ẃ{鎋H7b; =`\5>n_Gj7 u ӠΛsu:@y<9<]- m=S=MktG3^M $pN 7p= *x՞&saN7mdnD i0xΐx o.'Œȉp"+6w?L֧}_%zSsv"+.e!`)_{(THmOFlsԓZ+#ށ~偮G:܀KaJ/)bqd7[z"4HY<}X*
sDb|BnԦ hڽZ%
`QV;5K IASǻYvr_T-ph6D ԪjdDa{2h^^$pӨ8H˜4ͧV+!#RSVМ9aח77jw=: 5nZ
6^:f 09W_$lWsӒ۶UP}$}n
t¢f/koʍ+uߣɾ6n:eQeAr]//Z =:h ߸۾
=/^>
Y&l{x=ASNno @z f op]O!8W{(kn!Y'CP:}kYMR@RvLuٮN v7YOwC{6HtKm*uo ;-MH|uDovo wej'[&KAfa
f m#_B@秞Ozcލ dRb T>|Yaр]>Cedq3ddFx垖ɔz/'ŒQՠ =]Fn+wX2Y 2"S|3f 9cP{6UGvNwCAdDҠA6SB Xyz2 WDMHϮ\=`
rЮ Xcnh>paz+eD ^UU7mm0gNw;[O x7;$Y
/mfÍ'\s<~~jx& jD9 ƺoqNvu]uΟ`;7#-6C.R< ] vKk n Г`7hox98!'ZfX@A9ڂ
"4i*#A{7qn-pC xw9)ѮkʣnW͢b'bJ zYW!^HY@r m#"pCHtN3a+skp:7D"#
HtÛv NQ47G[! bfW #h71G[!{.\$:nV8btAsA&h Л/ ҨjUgnSL܇Ͻs烏v* l@ n5"7.6Ne32y
!{;tX222$-m}M
5rXOf㚆aʃ3hu-pos]݂-p xDu:݂74Ut;hEN|Ew]!y fwn"vد #M~x` \P??d}nj!j6x]9
KA
l1;
y zܦQ .C ;;R_Eq
RcMv 4^=qitv7~[ŚIM8btZ~\+L][A.
~n)xdAۛ>غo:hvp N!)vgfA0ǻ6TNsF:+ݦw[ l_꾭
p==`WU
"5 ozĥgUΜݜl}o}ǻ :j
CbW x ٫ʹ/ (RIf=>P48z6R=
L<8HƟSzֶfih3zeUWktAf zh*pDn.MFw F"MG7 ?d}m2PV:[Rݮ]LّũT8}uz 0P:tvPtY "NOLDh4 e> YZ )9@wlGE+m{LP pC BTMqAj7to{_S+hTyȰ\UsَwWz g)vgp s 7[ 6Yױ!td |o/?ߡ!U!7Kǻ'jtg]{\Іջ!|9H'{XO tg^ ֿ7䯺N` /hs9 xPj^, /_2
ɧ p;
"Q pHGY'zn9]A$,/xLS ѹW ۫{7 :Ž pH[;,p އGH(ğIn4^ (A2t kExu_.OOWxrzQ h*]} ^L'7Õpaz+A D
@-XͦTTǟuAr uA ؖ! n @ n @ n @ D D)I IENDB` (
/ 0 L D A r i a l 0 0 T T x ܖ F0ܖ " @ .
@ n ? " d d @ @@ `` S
7 7
2 1 >
"
@ - % % %
% &
$ $ $ $ $ R $ ⍶& e $ $ $ $ b $ J_ FPi@ 7$ 0 A A @ 0 w JG ʚ; ʚ; g 4 m d m d F0 p p p @ < 4 d d d d @0T x < 4 K d K d (A0T 8 0 _ _ _ P P T 1 0
?
% { * ELCOM Estuary Lake and Coastal Ocean Model + + # 9 Centre for Water Research
University of Western Australia : : Why calibrate?
6 Z Z Why calibrate? - To improve confidence in your predictions
6 - Z Z , , Model calibration M o d i f y i n g i n p u t p a r a m e t e r s u n t i l o u t p u t m a t c h e s a s e t o f f i e l d d a t a
a n i t e r a t i v e p r o c e d u r e o f p a r a m e t e r e v a l u a t i o n a n d r e f i n e m e n t , a s a r e s u l t o f c o m p a r i n g s i m u l a t e d a n d o b s e r v e d v a l u e s o f i n t e r e s t
6 Z Z ELCOM Calibration parameters ( 2 T h e r e a r e n t m a n y & .
6 Z Z ELCOM Calibration parameters ( T h e r e a r e n t m a n y & .
B o t t o m d r a g c o e f f i c i e n t i s r e a l l y t h e o n l y a v a i l a b l e c a l i b r a t i o n p a r a m e t e r ( r u n _ e l c o m . d a t f i l e )
B o t t o m d r a g , h o w e v e r , i s a l s o c o n t r o l l e d b y t h e n u m e r i c a l g r i d y o u c h o o s e .
I f y o u r m o d e l i s c o n f i g u r e d t o s i m u l a t e s u r f a c e t h e r m o d y n a m i c s , t h e n t h e l i g h t e x t i n c t i o n c o e f f i c i e n t i s a l s o a c a l i b r a t i o n p a r a m e t e r .
x Z ` Z K Z Z Z ` K & b
Calibrating for drag
G r i d d r a g
G r i d d r a g
Sensitivity analysis
Conducting sensitivity analysis (
A process to follow
V
0` 33 ` S f 3 f ` 33 g ` f ` www 3 PP ` ZX db mo ` \ ғ 3 y` Ӣ ` 3f 3f f ` 3f 3 FK f ` hk] www f ܹ ` ff >>\ `Y{ ff ` R>& - {p _/ ̴ > ? " d d @ , | ? " d d @ " @ ` n ? " d d @ @@ `` P R @ ` ` p > > (
6 " `}
T Click to edit Master title style !
! $
0 " `
R Click to edit Master text styles
Second level
Third level
Fourth level
Fifth level !
S
0 dȓ " ^ `
> *
0 ͓ " ^
@ *
0 ѓ " ^ `
@ * d
C . A L o g o T r a n s p " 0 0 H
0 h ? 3f 3 FK f 8 0 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 . /5N D e f a u l t D e s i g n 0 0
q (
~
s * a 0l
~
s * b @0
d
C . A T i t l e S l i d e " ` p
0 d ` `
a 1 Sensitivity analysis, calibration and validation
2 2 H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . `2.l + D= ' =
@B + a
0 x p H (
H ~
H s * { `}
~
H
s * | ~ `
^
H
6 ^
H
6 H
H 0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + a
0 x p (
~
s * T` `}
`
~
s * Z` ~ ` `
^
6 ^
6 H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + a
0 x p (
~
s * D` `}
`
~
s * 41` ~ ` `
^
6 ^
6 H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + a
0 x p (
~
s * ` `}
`
~
s * Q ~ ` `
^
6 ^
6 H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + a
0 x p (
~
s *
` `}
`
~
s * X` ~ ` `
^
6 ^
6 H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B +
0 @
= (
~
s * l3Q `
Q
^
6 ^
6 h
0 P2` o V N F _ _ _ P P T 9 (
J Run base model
Modify drag coefficient and re-run model
Change in results? . 2 < 2 < 8X C 8 @
@@
0 % " `
T " Grid sensitivity analysis required # ( 2 # @ @
@
0 6 " ` @
5 Yes ( 2
0 " ` @
F Calibration required ( 2 T
c $
0 " `
4 No ( 2 T
c $
` H
0 h ? / @
33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B +
0 $
(
~
s * f` `}
`
^
6 ^
6
B CP
D E0 F8 A A > p@p@ P
@ " `
@
B C
D E F A A jJ ``
@ " ` `
0 =Q `PG
j : A coarser vertical grid will result in more numerical drag ; 2 ; d B
< F ` ` H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + #
0 : 2 P
(
~
s * ~Q `}
Q
^
6 ^
6
# B CP
D E0 F8 > p@p@ P
@ " `
@
# B C
D E F jJ ``
@ " ` `
0 Q `PG
j : A coarser vertical grid will result in more numerical drag ; 2 ; d B
< F ` `
0 Q
CDGrid > CDActual D 2 $
0 h P
CDGrid < CDActual D 2 $ H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B +
0
6 (
~
s * ` `}
`
^
6 ^
6
0 0cQ P
L A s s e s s m e n t o f t h e m o d e l s e t - u p s h o u l d a l s o b e c o n s i d e r e d p a r t o f t h e m o d e l c a l i b r a t i o n p r o c e s s .
T y p i c a l l y , t h i s i s k n o w n a s s e n s i t i v i t y a n a l y s i s
F o r E L C O M , t h i s i n c l u d e s a n a s s e s s m e n t o f t h e s e n s i t i v i t y o f t h e m o d e l r e s u l t s t o t h e s e l e c t i o n o f t h e f o l l o w i n g :
t i m e s t e p
h o r i z o n t a l g r i d r e s o l u t i o n
v e r t i c a l g r i d r e s o l u t i o n
l o c a t i o n o f t h e o p e n b o u n d a r y c o n d i t i o n s
@ 2 l 2 2 l H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B +
0 #
(
~
s * 4` `}
`
^
6 ^
6 )
0 zQ PK
1 Requires running different model configurations to understand how important an individual decision is in the model results.
Complexity of the analysis
Running different timesteps is relatively straightforward.
Running new vertical resolution tests is relatively straightforward, as only minor changes are required to the bathymetry file.
Changes to the open boundary locations are relatively complex, as require new forcing data to be generated
Changes to the horizontal grid resolution are time consuming, as they require the generation of a new grid.
Z ~ 2 2 2 2 ~ | H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + [
0 r j 0
(
~
s * 8` `}
`
^
6 ^
6 x
0 t P P H @ _ _ _ P P T 9 "
@ R u n t h e b a s e m o d e l .
M o d i f y t h e d r a g c o e f f i c i e n t a n d c o m p a r e r e s u l t s w i t h t h e b a s e m o d e l .
M o d i f y t h e t i m e s t e p a n d c o m p a r e r e s u l t s .
M o d i f y t h e v e r t i c a l g r i d r e s o l u t i o n a n d c o m p a r e r e s u l t s .
D e t e r m i n e w h e t h e r n u m e r i c a l d r a g i s a f a c t o r o r n o t .
M o d i f y t h e h o r i z o n t a l g r i d r e s o l u t i o n b y c r e a t i n g a n e w g r i d o f f i n e r r e s o l u t i o n , r e - c o n f i g u r e t h e m o d e l a n d c o m p a r e r e s u l t s .
N o t e t h i s c a n a l l b e d o n e w i t h o u t a n y f i e l d d a t a . I t i s n o t a c a l i b r a t i o n p r o c e s s , i t i s a p r o c e s s o f u n d e r s t a n d i n g h o w s e n s i t i v e t h e m o d e l i s t o c e r t a i n c o n f i g u r a t i o n s .
, r 2 2 r d 8X H
0 h ? 33 _ _ _ P P T 1 0 i . st + D= ' =
@B + rP 0 @$ ( @ . {+ M2 5 ` B EP V \ 9 H # Se 1 Oh +'0 h p
( Lakes and the carbon cycle Jason Antenucci antenucc 175 Microsoft Office PowerPoint @ a @ Pí@ NK G h g ,V ' & " WMFC <8 ? @ A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z [ \ ] ^ _ ` a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o q r s t u v w x y z { | } ~ R o o t E n t r y dO ) P i c t u r e s C u r r e n t U s e r S u m m a r y I n f o r m a t i o n ( ȭ P o w e r P o i n t D o c u m e n t ( p e D o c u m e n t S u m m a r y I n f o r m a t i o n 8